WAR Graph Wednesday: Carlos Baerga and Fernando Vina (and Kolten Wong?)

by on June 8, 2011 · 0 comments

On Tuesday night, the Cardinals selected University of Hawaii second baseman Kolten Wong with their first round pick (22nd overall) in Major League Baseball’s First Year Player Draft.

Immediately reactions went off across Cardinal Nation – “typical uninspired pick” versus “upside at a need position” rang throughout the Twitterverse.

Future Redbirds obviously was all over things with a post covering many items that tell us more about Wong.

The early comparisons have ranged from Fernando Vina (hey!) to Carlos Baerga.  So which is it?  Or, more appropriately, which would you prefer?

Click image to see full-size

Well, this graph is just a bit silly to look at, isn’t it? Holy smokes, Baerga was quick out of the gate, eh?  And then…well… On the other hand, Vina, slow and steady, ups and downs.

It bears noting, if even necessary, that Vina was more valuable defensively over his career.  That doesn’t really present itself glaringly in any of these graphs, but worth noting, nonetheless.

Click image to see full-size

Ultimately, we see that the mean is more comparative here than the median. Baerga had big years, but also some extremely negative years that Vina was not subject to.

Finally, as has been the case with many of these, we get to a graph that allows some “perspective”:

Click image to see full-size

So, we’d all obviously love for Kolten Wong to turn out to be Carlos Baerga, right?  (Well, maybe most of us – those scarred by this year’s defense would never wish that upon another Cardinals team.)  At any rate, it’s important to remember that, for better or worse, Fernando Vina has been one of the better second basemen this team has seen in recent years (see: Cardinals Team of the Decade : 2000-2009 and Cardinals 2000 and 2010 Roster Mashup).

For me, I’d be happy to see Wong turn into something in between – still some value in that, no?

Writing about the Cardinals and other loosely associated topics since 2008, I've grown tired of the April run-out only to disappoint Cardinal fans everywhere by mid-May. I do not believe in surrendering free outs.
View all posts by Nick
Follow Nick on Twitter

Comments on this entry are closed.

Previous post:

Next post: