Q&A with Erik from Future Redbirds

by on July 24, 2008 · 15 comments

With the trade deadline fast approaching, and every post I write seemingly spouting off about “why can’t we trade this minor-leaguer for an All-Star?”, I thought it appropriate to get some information from a better source.  Erik from Future Redbirds was gracious enough to take the time to answer some (admittedly) off-the-cuff questions about the state of the organization below the St Louis level and who could potentially be moved.

First, if you were an opposing GM, and taking organizational needs that most teams emphasize when making trades out of the equation, how would you rate the top 10-15 Cardinal prospects on a “tiered” basis?  Most discussion around trade rumors centers on Tier 1 prospects, Tier 2 prospects, and so on.  How do you see the top Cards’ prospects on that scale?

Good question.  The new draft picks won’t be on any GM’s list because they aren’t tradeable commodities yet, but if I were a GM I would put tier one as Colby Rasmus and probably Brett Wallace.  Tier two would be Chris Perez and Bryan Anderson.  Tier three would include Jaime Garcia, Clayton Mortensen, Jess Todd, Daryl Jones and Pete Kozma.  Lance Lynn probably would fit in that category as well.  Next would be Mitch Boggs, Jon Jay, Adam Ottavino, Joe Mather, Tyler Herron and Nico Vasquez.  Vasquez could be jumping tiers rather quickly based on his numbers.  I’d be rather curious to get a scouts’ view on him.

Much has been made of the Cardinals’ bullpen struggles of late. Assuming guys like Mitch Boggs, Jaime Garcia, and Mike Parisi are assumed to be starters in the organization, are there any internal options at reliever that are big-league ready in the organization? Should we expect to see Chris Perez back sooner than later? Is Mark Worrell still too unpolished to be counted on?

Chris Perez just needs to find his lost slider.  Once he does that, he would hands down be the best choice. Mark Worrell is someone who deserves more of a look but should only be brought in to face right-handed batters.  I think he has been overlooked, and with his funky delivery he would give batters something to think about.  One thing that I notice about the big league pen is that Springer, Izzy, Franklin, and McClellan are not vastly different than each other stuff wise.  They’re not exact copies, but they don’t really offer opponents a different look like a Perez (who is a flamethrower) or a Worrell (who is just plain funky) does.

Obviously Colby Rasmus is the “top dog” in the Cards organization and future plans, and trade talk surrounding him has been shouted down by the Cardinal management. Are there any other players that GM John Mozeliak should absolutely refuse to trade as the deadline approaches?

I don’t think anyone should be regarded untouchable after Colby.  For the right deal I think anyone is tradeable.  Anderson is the best chip they have right now, and he is just about certain to be traded at some point- either this month, this winter, or next July.  I think his value could be close to peaking right now.  I’d also offer up the conspiracy that he hasn’t been named to Team USA yet because he is going to be traded soon.

Can Jaime Garcia or Mitchell Boggs be counted on as a fifth starter for the Cardinals as the organization patiently waits for Adam Wainwright and/or Chris Carpenter to get healthy? It seems as if one of these guys may be counted on as a regular starter down the stretch.

Absolutely, I think both Garcia and Boggs have already shown they have the stuff to pitch in the big leagues.  I’d prefer Boggs, as Garcia probably needs more time in the minors.  Boggs is pretty much a one-dimensional hurler, but I think he can have some Jason Marquis-like value as a 5th starter.

The Cards have, for a few years now, put together a makeshift middle infield to begin the season. Is there relief on the way in the system? Can Pete Kozma and Nico Vasquez eventually provide answers at 2B and SS?

It’s a little too early to fully determine, but both certainly have big league upside or they wouldn’t have been drafted as high as they were.  I certainly am hoping to see it, as Vasquez represents a power bat at the keystone, and by all accounts Kozma should be able to reach the majors on the strength of his glove alone.  He may not be the bat they were hoping for out of the first round, but we can hope can get rid of that slappy swing of his.

With Ankiel, Ludwick, and Rasmus being touted as the Cardinal outfield of the near future – which of the many minor league outfielders that are nearing or at “major-league ready” do you think are most available and most attractive to other teams in a trade? It would seem that at least one or more of Chris Duncan, Skip Schumaker, Brian Barton, Joe Mather, Nick Stavinoha, and/or Shane Robinson would be plenty available for a trade around this year’s deadline.

There are a glut of outfielders, but I’m not certain any of them will fetch you much in a trade.  Obviously Barton and Duncan are not available because they are on the disabled list.  That makes Skip non-expendable for the moment.  Mather, Robinson and Stavinoha might not fetch a lot, but Mather has the most value of the three for his plus power.  Robinson has really struggled in AAA after hitting unconscious in AA, and Stavinoha doesn’t profile as more than a 4th OF because of his lack of patience and lack of power.  He has some power, just not what you’d like to see out of a corner OF.  He has one tool-hitting for average.  He’s like a big Aaron Miles in an outfield corner.  Looking at the recent past, Terry Evans, who is sorta similar to Mather, got the Cards Jeff Weaver.  Sean Danielson, who is similar to Robinson, got us Joel Pineiro.

What’s the best package you could put together from the Cards’ organization for Orioles reliever George Sherrill? Brian Fuentes? And one name that probably isn’t on the tip of every Cardinal fan right now – Mark Ellis?

I think Sherrill’s price is bound to be inflated because of the amount of saves he’s racked up, and the O’s reportedly are wanting starting pitching and a middle infielder.  Former 1st round pick Tyler Greene may interest them, but I think it would also take Jaime Garcia to get it done and I don’t know if the Cardinals would be willing to do that.  As for the others, I’d just forget Fuentes.  O’Dowd’s asking prices are completely insane–I’m sure he’d demand Colby and more.  Not happening.  As for Ellis, I’m not sure what he offers that Jarrett Hoffpauir couldn’t do at a cheaper rate.  I’d sooner call up KC and find out what it would take to get the ageless Grudz back.  They should’ve met his contract demands in the first place.

If you were John Mozeliak and had to make one deal to better the big-league club this season, but not mortgage the future of the organization in any way – what would that trade be?

I’d see if I couldn’t talk Baltimore into taking Greene and Anthony Reyes for Sherrill, but that would be a stretch and I’m sure a little lopsided.  If they were OK with Greene but didn’t like Reyes, maybe they’d like Herron or Ottavino instead.  I dunno. I’m not sure I like how this trade deadline is working out for Mozeliak, I certainly don’t envy him right now.

Finally, shock Cardinal Nation. Make a wild prediction of a deal that will be made – prospects or not – that no one who follows the Cardinals will be expecting.

OK, but this is totally random: Huston Street and Alan Embree for Bryan Anderson, Jess Todd, Joe Mather and Tommy Pham.


I tried to piggy-back a final question onto the list just as Erik was answering these.  That question was about whether Bryan Anderson really had a future with the Cardinals, given that Yadier Molina is firmly entrenched at catcher with the big club.  I quickly found out that he had already answered that question pretty definitively above, expecting Anderson to move sooner than later.

I hope this provides some good insight into the farm system and its impact on the trading deadline – I know I learned a lot from Erik’s much-appreciated time.

If you want to learn more and keep up with the youngsters, please visit Future Redbirds, they have lots of good information over there.

Thanks again Erik!

Writing about the Cardinals and other loosely associated topics since 2008, I've grown tired of the April run-out only to disappoint Cardinal fans everywhere by mid-May. I do not believe in surrendering free outs.
View all posts by Nick
Follow Nick on Twitter


Fatal error: Cannot assign by reference to overloaded object in /homepages/27/d90113456/htdocs/wp-content/themes/thesis_15/lib/classes/comments.php on line 176